Medical News Discussion Group, April 2023

  • The transgenderism issue is rapidly gaining importance. Jim and Holly Gruhl reported on an interview by Jordan Peterson of Dr. Miriam Grossman. The number of young persons claiming to be trans or nonbinary has rapidly climbed to 20% and with the pervasive influence of social media could reach 40%. Dr. Grossman states that the transgender ideology is based on the fraudulent work of John Money. While children may be pushed into treatment by therapists who threaten that the child may commit suicide if not “transitioned,” those who do transition are also at risk. In addition, parents, children, and other family members are deeply affected and may also commit suicide, a problem that is largely being ignored. Legal and legislative pushback is growing, along with strong challenges in public forums, as by Matt Walsh. TG activists are increasingly advocating violence.

    Dr. Money’s foundational study involved twin boys, one of whom was severely injured by a botched circumcision. He was castrated and raised as a girl. Despite claims about “success,” the patient did not identify as a girl and eventually committed suicide.

    Dr. Gruhl added that while 20% of high schoolers now claim they are nonbinary, only one in ten of those has ever dated someone of the same biological birth gender. This would suggest the claim may represent “virtue sIgnaling.” Jordan Peterson discusses the most important transitions in growing up are ages 2 to 4 and ages 16 to 20. In the 16-to-20 group, youth are “burying their youth to become adult” and are looking for heroic causes, which they often find in music, protests, and rebellions. Previous cultures used this growth period to instill patriotism.
  • Holly Gruhl commented on the increasing difficulty that patients, especially Medicare patients, have in finding medical care, including physicians’ willingness to respond promptly to questions about abnormal lab tests. She attended a talk by Li Schmidt, M.D., of Tucson, who presented interesting thoughts on wellness. She also provided information about new services and subscription plans with Dr. Pierre Kory, who is working with certified tribal healers. The Association of American Physicians and Surgeons has been interested in potential “medical tourism” to tribal lands to find physicians and methods that are disfavored by establishment medicine and Big Pharma.
  • Post-COVID situation: Holly Gruhl, who frequently attends Tucson Symphony Orchestra performances, observed that there were many new musicians. TSO conductor Jose Gomez commented from the podium that there had been many deaths. Also, the audience was much diminished—half the seats were empty. TSO requires vaccination to attend. This anecdotal evidence suggest that the vaccine rollout has not been accompanied by a “return to normality.”
  • Mortality rates: Dr. Gruhl presented information from financial analyst Ed Dowd, author of ‘Cause Unknown’: The Epidemic of Sudden Deaths in 2021 & 2022, who used data provided by Josh Stirling, concerning an alarming increase in excess deaths associated with the COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Dr. Orient asked a retired Arizona actuary about this. He provided the appended report from the Society of Actuaries, and the following comments:

    “The Society of Actuaries regularly does several life insurance mortality studies for different purposes, such as Group Term Life, Group Conversion life, Individual Term Life, Individual Whole Life, Disabled Lives, and the U. S. population overall. Each of these studies are usually replicated by counting (a) Reported Claims – based on when the claim was received by the insurer, (b) Incurred Claim – based on the date of death, and (c) Claim Amounts – i.e., based on how much each life was insured for. Usually, these data are also adjusted based on the age of the respective population. While you may not want to bother reading the attached (and I only briefly skimmed through it to see where things stand), let me draw your attention to tables 2.1 – 2.4, 3.1, 3.3, 4.1 and 4.3. Each of these tables shows a large mortality impact in 2020, followed by a larger impact in 2021, falling in Q1 2022, and almost back to the normal baseline by Q2 2022 (April – June 2022).”

    Dr. Gruhl noted that he looked through the SOA report and, probably for political reasons, they did not break out any vaccinated/unvaccinated data. They have that data, as insurance companies collect HIPAA Privacy information, and there is every reason to believe people would be glad to report their “virtuous” vaccinated status. Josh Stirling broke out that vaccinated data, which Ed Dowd used. They reported that insurance companies strongly pushed, or mandated, vaccines and it would be 25 years before they broke out those vaccinated for higher premiums because of higher risk—so, everyone would have to bear those increases.

    Dr. Gruhl also said that he was not sure what the swing up and then back down in SOA death rates implies about vaccine deaths. World death rates are continually up about 20% beginning late 2020. Plus, birth rates are down about 20%, with mechanisms directly associated with vaccines. There is also evidence from the UK and Israel that excess mortality is occurring.

    Hospitals have claimed that death rates are nine times higher in the unvaccinated. However, Dr Gruhl notes that hospitals know that a person is vaccinated if the hospital gave the vaccine, but otherwise the patient may be lumped into the unvaccinated category.

Regarding the Ukraine war, Dr. Gruhl provided a link to a Jordan Peterson’s interview of Sen. Mike Lee, discussing the problem of lack of a clear objective and the enormous expenditure ($113 billion) with little oversight: 173) Russia/Ukraine, ESG, Gigantism and the West | Senator Mike Lee | EP 346 – YouTube.

Doctors for Disaster Preparedness (DDP) Reviews New WHO Advice on COVID Vaccines

Updated guidance on COVID vaccination by the World Health Organization (WHO) states that only high-risk groups should receive ongoing booster doses because they offer little impact in the general population. Instead, efforts should focus on high-risk populations.

Notably, WHO assigns the lowest priority to healthy children and adolescents aged six months to 17 years, states Doctors for Disaster Preparedness (DDP) president Jane M. Orient, M.D.

In low-to-medium risk groups, the benefit of additional boosters is “actually quite marginal, based on what we know of the immune status of these people,” stated Hanna Nohynek, chair of WHO’s Strategic Advisory Group of Experts on Immunization (SAGE).

Priority groups, according to SAGE, are principally defined based on risk of severe disease and death. Considerations include vaccine performance, cost-effectiveness, programmatic factors, and community acceptance. The high priority group includes older persons, pregnant persons, and frontline health workers.

WHO’s assumption about effectiveness against severe disease and death has been challenged on the basis of inadequate evidence, Dr. Orient points out. Pregnant persons were excluded from vaccine trials, and SAGE does not comment on pregnancy outcomes. Some physicians consider safety signals significant enough to warrant withdrawal of COVID-19 vaccines from the market.

SAGE considers both the primary series and boosters to be safe. It urges countries to base their decisions on “contextual factors, such as the disease burden, cost effectiveness, and other health or programmatic priorities and opportunity costs.”

DDP urges decisionmakers to review WHO’s revised guidance, as well as other views, in making risk-to-benefit assessments.Doctors for Disaster Preparedness provides information to help save lives in the event of natural or man-made disasters.

Doctors for Disaster Preparedness (DDP) Invites Participation in Medical News Discussion

Opportunities for doctors to get together and share their views have become rare, partly because of the rise of managed care and the decline of independently owned practices. Additionally, many medical society meetings were cancelled or became virtual because of COVID and have not resumed. The Tucson Medical News Discussion Group, comprised of physicians and nonphysicians who were members of a society’s public health committee until it was disbanded, continues to meet to discuss health-related issues of general interest. The group is now posting summaries and inviting participation, states Doctors for Disaster Preparedness (DDP) president Jane M. Orient, M.D.

Recent postings concern “turbo cancer,” actuarial reports of excess deaths, flying objects, depopulation trends, and effects of increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide and mitigation measures. They can be found on https://www.ddponline.org under the “press releases” tab and on Facebook. Comments may be submitted on the DDP website, or can be entered and shared on Facebook.

Older postings can be seen on facebook.com; search for “medical news discussion.” Besides COVID, topics include marijuana, obesity, PANDAS (Pediatric Autoimmune Neuropsychiatric Disorder Associated with Strep), vitamin A deficiency, drug shortages, and changes in medical practice.

“Confining physicians’ and patients’ information sources to official pronouncements stifles innovation and obstructs recognition of developing problems,” states Dr. Orient. “First-hand contact with persons in the real world, and open discussion, are critical for our health and safety.”

Doctors for Disaster Preparedness provides information to help save lives in the event of natural or man-made disasters.

Registration Open! DDP 2023 Annual Meeting

The 41st Annual Meeting of Doctors for Disaster Preparedness will be in
Tucson, AZ at the Doubletree Tucson – Reid Park, July 7-9, 2023.

Saturday and Sunday (July 8-9) will be two days full of presentations from an all-star lineup of speakers!  Stay tuned for an announcement of this year’s agenda. We promise it will be a meeting you will NOT want to miss.

The welcome reception will be Friday evening (July 7) from 7pm to 9pm.

An optional group outing will be held on Friday afternoon to the ASARCO copper mine just south of Tucson. We are looking at options for a Friday morning activity as well.

In addition to in-person registration, a virtual attendance option is also available. Both in-person and virtual attendees will have access to the meeting video archive for 1-month following the event.

Meeting registration:https://aaps.wufoo.com/forms/q1li2ixt1vs5vi7/

Hotel room reservation (group rate $96/night, cutoff date June 6): 
https://www.hilton.com/en/book/reservation/deeplink/?ctyhocn=TUSBTDT&groupCode=CDTD4D&arrivaldate=2023-07-06&departuredate=2023-07-10&cid=OM,WW,HILTONLINK,EN,DirectLink&fromId=HILTONLINKDIRECT

WW III? Reply to Glenn Beck on Nuclear War

Do you have insurance for the worst-case scenario?

This week on Glenn TV, Glenn Beck presented “How to Prepare for the HORRIFYING Reality of Nuclear War” (Ep 254), to awaken Americans to a threat they probably hadn’t thought about for a long time. “Mr. Beck has done a great service to our nation in his spell-binding account of the acute nuclear war danger facing our nation now,” states Doctors for Disaster Preparedness (DDP).

“Mr. Beck is correct in saying that the threat of nuclear war has never been so high, and Americans are totally unprepared,” states DDP president Jane M. Orient, M.D. “Still, he unwittingly promotes some dangerous myths that might discourage people from taking simple precautions.”

DDP offers the following factual information:

  • The “duck and cover drill” that Beck like so many others ridicules would save millions of lives in those areas far enough from the bomb where flying glass and debris would be the main hazard.
  • Any type of shadow or cover can prevent burns from the thermal flash. At Hiroshima, skin under white clothing was protected, while skin under dark colors was burned.
  • There is no fallout of significance if a nuclear warhead is air burst.
  • Fallout from a ground burst decays rapidly by the “7-10 rule.” At 7 hours after detonation, the radioactivity would be decreased to 10% of the initial level, and at 49 hours, to 1% of the initial level. It does not take 2 weeks to fall to that level.
  • Fallout is visible (it looks like sand or grit). Levels can be measured easily—unfortunately, the U.S. destroyed most of its appropriate instruments, but Beck does not mention that fact, or the alternatives available to or makeable by the public.
  • The nuclear winter theory was thoroughly debunked in 1986.

“We thank Mr. Beck for raising awareness and hope that Americans will be stimulated to increase their knowledge and level of preparedness,” stated Dr. Orient.

Doctors for Disaster Preparedness provides information to help save lives in the event of natural or man-made disasters.

Tucson Medical News Discussion Group

Tucson Medical News Discussion Group

Our group meets in person most months to discuss issues of the day pertaining to public health and safety. An early project was to set up the “Medical News Discussion” on facebook.com. Early posts are still available—please comment and share—except that FB (now Meta) censored some of them. Members of the group previously served on the Public Health Committee of the Pima County (Arizona) Medical Society until PCMS eliminated the committee as being unnecessary.

Members include Holly Gruhl, R.N., Jane Orient, M.D., and James Gruhl, Ph.D. Dr. Orient practices general internal medicine and is president of Doctors for Disaster Preparedness. Dr. Gruhl earned a doctorate in systems science at MIT, which included environmental impacts of electric power generation. He researched and taught at MIT and retired from there. In 1969-1970, he helped write the Clean Air Act, which set up the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and served on the EPA Science Advisory Board from 1976 until 1992. From 1976 until 1985, he was a principal investigator for Harvard School of Public Health projects on health effects of energy production; health effects of air pollution; heavy metals pollution; combustion products effects on health; and climate effects on world food production, population, species diversity, and extinctions. In 1995-1996 he chaired the Clinton Committee on the Kyoto Climate Treaty and studies models of climate and CO2 and effects on vegetation and global temperature.

Meeting Notes:

https://www.ddponline.org/2023/01/03/mednews-january-2023/

https://www.ddponline.org/2023/02/03/mednews-february-2023/

https://www.ddponline.org/2023/03/24/mednews-march-2023/

MedNews March 2023

  • Dr. Orient reported that the spring issue (https://jpands.org/jpands2801.htm) of the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons will have several articles on COVID-19 vaccines: evidence pertaining to the effect of the vaccines on mitigating severe disease; obstetrical adverse reported to VAERS for COVID vs. influenza vaccines, and negative evidence pertaining to cancer.
  • The origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus is now the subject of public scrutiny. Dr. Gruhl pointed out an aspect not getting much attention: the tens of millions for gain-of-function research funneled to places other than the Wuhan Institute of Virology, including the Chinese Military Medical Sciences (biowarfare) facility.
  • Transgenderism, previously believed to affect about 0.6% of the population is now said to affect 20%. The manifestations are of dizzying complexity.
  • Holly Gruhl remarked on the continuing paucity of person-to-person communication, and the refusal of so many, including family members and long-time friends, to communicate with persons who do not fully accept the narrative. Naomi Wolf writes about this extensively in The Bodies of Others. She believes this is one effect of COVID lockdowns and constant fearmongering. She states that children lost about 20 IQ points, and also manual dexterity as they did little except play Nintendo. Dr. Gruhl stated facts don’t matter any more. Most people brainwashed and get anxious and agitated when confronted with facts that dispute the accepted Narrative. We are in the Allegory of Plato’s Cave, he states, where the inhabitants viciously attack those who try to tell them about reality.
  • The supposed “scientific” basis for masking and lockdown mandates is under attack, as in the Cochrane review on mask mandates. The basic rationale depends on asymptomatic transmission. Dr. Gruhl noted that the Chinese did a gigantic study. On 30th Nov 2020 it was reported that “A mass screening programme of more than 10 million Wuhan residents identified 300 asymptomatic cases, but none were infectious—according to a study involving the University of East Anglia. The study found no ‘viable’ virus in the asymptomatic cases and the close contacts of these positive asymptomatic cases did not test positive.” (UEA,2020, Science Daily, Nov 30, 2020. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201130131511.htm)
  • Suppressed treatments and the question “What Happened to Evidence Based Medicine?” are discussed by FLCCC, Dr. Gruhl pointed out, at https://odysee.com/@FrontlineCovid19CriticalCareAlliance:c/Weekly_Webinar_March08:7.
  • World depopulation is occurring. China’s population is closer to 800,000,000 than 1.4 billion, based on cell phone data, Dr. Gruhl stated. Officials have strong incentives to overstate population numbers. Population may soon decrease by 25% per generation. Each person in China produces an average of 0.25 offspring, which means China’s 1.4 billion will be down to about 320 million by the year 2100. Totalitarian governments cause despondency and lack of desire to have children. Many factors are contributing to depopulation, including food shortages, impoverishment, pandemic control measures as well as the emerging pathogens themselves, and the LGBTQ phenomenon.
  • The war in Ukraine escalates. Dr. Gruhl notes that if Putin dies or is “taken out,” the Russian Federation might split into several regions ruled by warlords equipped with hydrogen bombs. He believes supporters of the war are not considering this consequence.

Doctors for Disaster Preparedness (DDP) Urges Caution in Assigning Blame for SARS-CoV-2 Virus

Current intense controversy concerns whether the SARS-CoV-2 virus, the causative agent for COVID-19, came from nature or from a laboratory. And if the latter, was it an accidental or a deliberate release?

Doctors for Disaster Preparedness (DDP) asks: How can we establish a definitive answer, and what action would be advisable?

Some proponents of a laboratory origin have focused attention on a virologist at a major American university. An enormous fire occurred at a laboratory at that university (coincidentally?), despite its sprinkler system, causing extensive damage on multiple floors.

“What is achieved by ‘doxing’ an individual scientist, even if the scientist is guilty?” asks DDP president Jane Orient, M.D. “Killing Osama bin Laden did not remove the terrorist threat. And accusing the wrong man diverts attention from the real culprits and discredits the accusers.”

DDP makes several observations:

  • It seems unlikely that an evil scientist bent on making a bioweapon to kill millions would work openly at a public university and patent his product.
  • The actual product may not be the same as an accuser claims. It is important to read the patent first-hand. For example, one patent claimed to be a “smoking gun” actually concerned developing a veterinary vaccine against porcine transmissible gastroenteritis (TGE), a plague that kills pigs en masse.
  • Molecular biology is a highly complex subject. Most physicians do not have the expertise to independently assess claims by “experts” that they may be repeating.
  • Animal infections (zoonoses) do have the potential to “jump species” and infect humans (e.g., Ebola). SARS-CoV-1, which is the “older brother” of SARS-CoV-2 but not the same, evidently did so. Thus, we need sophisticated labs for monitoring.
  • Any technology can be used for good or ill.
  • There are hundreds of laboratories, many funded by the U.S., capable of making bioweapons—or defenses against same, located in the U.S., Ukraine, China, or unknown locations. China has reportedly been working explicitly on bioweapons and genetic weapons.

“Our first priority should be effective pandemic response, which COVID-19 revealed to be woefully lacking,” Dr. Orient stated. “We need to investigate the source, but premature accusations, which may terrorize scientists, are counterproductive.”

MedNews February 2023

  • Reports of “turbo-cancer” began to appear after the COVID-19 vaccine rollout. People including committee members are aware of acquaintances with unusual, very aggressive cancers. Dr. Jane Orient is completing an article “Negative Evidence: COVID-10 Vaccines and Cancer.” Negative evidence is the surprising absence of research that one would expect to be prioritized by government and academia, given growing public concerns.
  • Dr. Gruhl noted Josh Stirling’s actuarial reports of a 145% increase in deaths of persons who received just one dose of COVID vaccine, and an overall increase of 40%. Life insurers will not be asking questions about vaccination status but will increase rates across the board.
  • Dr. James Gruhl also called attention to the recent paper by Fauci et al. in Cell concerning the need for better approaches to vaccines for respiratory viruses. He wrote: “It is not surprising that none of the predominantly mucosal respiratory viruses have ever been effectively controlled by vaccines.” One problem is failure to stimulate mucosal immunity. (https://www.cell.com/cell-host-microbe/fulltext/S1931-3128(22)00572-8). Is Dr Fauci backtracking on his aggressive calls for more COVID vaccination? Is he concerned about legal consequences? Dr. Gruhl states that in the book Spike by Jeremy Farrar of the Wellcome Trust, Farrar writes how he, Bill Gates, and Anthony Fauci used burner phones to discuss the modification of the coronavirus.
  • Dr. Gruhl stated that Peter Daszak, of Eco Health Alliance, redirected Fauci money to Wuhan in 2018 to add the furin cleavage site to the coronavirus so it could get into human cells and replicate and become more lethal. Peter Daszak filed with the US Department of Defense for a patent on the addition of a furin cleavage site to a coronavirus to facilitate cell entry, as by a bioweapon (“The Daszak Strain,” https://eco-healthalliance.org/, which includes email from Daszak to colleagues.)
  • Dr. Gruhl stated that the RNA in COVID vaccines has pseudouridine instead of uridine, which makes the RNA more stable. One effect is that it remains in the body much longer. There may be other, unknown effects. Also, according to a Pfizer whistleblower, different lots contain different numbers of ingredients.
  • The flying objects that have been shot down over the U.S. are Chinese surveillance devices, states Dr. Gruhl. They are not a threat to people on the ground. They are probably monitoring communications with our ICBMs.
  • Holly Gruhl, R.N., reported watching a recent panel discussion featuring medical students or residents and thinking how thoroughly indoctrinated they were in unquestionable following of protocol.
  • The world political situation was discussed. Klaus Schwab recently received a vote of no confidence. Only Olaf Scholz of the G7 attended a recent meeting. The most prominent members of the WEF in charge of main objectives (e.g. King Charles on the energy agenda and Bill Gates on eugenics) are aging. Problems with succession in the U.S. given Biden’s age and deteriorating health were also discussed.

MedNews January 2023

  • Actuaries report extraordinarily high excess death rates in persons between ages 18 and 50, which will have a devastating impact on the insurance industry. These are just numbers of deaths from all causes. Curiously, the rate is highest in persons receiving a single dose of a COVID-19 vaccine.
  • It is predicted that that as many as 4 billion humans will die of starvation, owing to measures such as limits on nitrogen fertilizer. Dr. James Gruhl stated that the rationale for the limits is to prevent a theoretical global temperature rise of 0.1 degree Fahrenheit by 2100, which would be virtually unmeasurable.
  • Dr. Gruhl reminded the committee of his graph showing CO2 levels and measures of the earth’s lushness over geological time, and the optimum levels for various temperatures. Optimum is about 2500 ppm, current is 420 ppm, no life on Earth is 150 ppm—the worst possible public health problem.
  • Dr. Gruhl has spoken with Dr. Richard Lindzen of MIT, who states that the climate change crisis is a hoax, but any criticism will be suppressed, and editors who permit publication of critical articles have been immediately fired.
  • The World Economic Forum conference in Davos concluded with an impassioned speech by Klaus Schwab declaring that persons spreading the idea that globalists meant to take over the world would be canceled.
  • Dr. Gruhl reported that the U.S. electric grid could be shut down for months if key points were disabled, resulting in death of a large fraction of the population.
  • Investors are withdrawing funds from Wells Fargo, BlackRock, and Vanguard because of the anticipated effect of ESG policies on investment returns. Companies are now walking back or denying their statements about ESG.